Name, approximate year of birth, country of birth, occupation, from USA 1875 New York State Census for Catskill, Greene County, found in June 2019:
Name: Eugene Benit
Age: 73
Gender: Male
Birth Year: abt 1802
Residence Date: 1 Jun 1875
Residence Place: Catskill, Greene, New York, USA
Election District: E.D. 04
Household number: 170
Relation to Head: Father-in-law
Spouse's name: Elizabeth Benit
Born: Greene
Occupation: Hatter [Makes, sells, or repairs hats]
Line Number: 14
Sheet Number: 19
Household Members:
Name Age
Benjamin Overbaugh 25
Frances Overbaugh 26
Eugene Benit 73
Elizabeth Benit 63

Result, from USA 1865 New York State Census for Town of Ashland, Greene County, found in June 2019:
Name: Eugene P Bennet
Gender: Male
Relation to Head: Head
Birth Year: abt 1802
Age: 63
Residence: Ashland, Greene, New York, USA
Line Number: 25
Page Number: 34
Household Members:
Name Age
Eugene P Bennet 63
Elisabeth B Bennet 53
Frances M Bennet 20 [Teacher]
Henry Kinsley 37 [Boarder]