Name from baptism record of son, James, from the US Dutch Reformed Church Records for Katskill Conewaga PA and Six Mile Run NJII, Book 77, for Catskill, New York, page 141 found in June 2019:
Name: James Overbagh
Mother: Gitty DeWith
Father: Peter J Overbagh
Birth: May 3 1817
Baptism: Sep 4, 1817

Approximate year of death from Minutebook of New York Wills and Probate Records, page 576, found in June 2019:
Name: Peter J Overbaugh
Probate Date: 27/12/1870
Probate Place: Greene New York USA
Inferred Death Year: Abt 1870
Inferred Death Place: New York USA
Item Description: Minutebook, Vol I-J, 1864-1887

Approximate year and place of birth, month/year of death, place of death, from the New York State Census Mortality Schedules for Catskill, in the County of Greene, for persons who died during the year ending 1st June 1870, page 2, found in June 2019:
Name: Peter J Overbaugh
Age: 75
Race: White
Gender: Male
Marital status: Widow
Birth Year: abt 1795
Place of Birth: New York
Month of Death: Jan
Place of Death: Catskill, Greene, New York
Census Year: 1870

Baptism record of son, Henry Demott Overbagh, found in US Dutch Reformed Church Records for Katskill Conewaga PA and Six Mile Run NJII, Book 77, for Catskill, New York, page 150 found in June 2019:
Name: Peter J Overbagh
Gender: Male
Spouse: Getty Dewitt
Child: Henry Demott Overbagh

Result from USA 1855 New York State Census for Town Catskill, Greene County, found in June 2019.

Name: Peter J Overbaugh
Birth Year: abt 1796
Age: 59
Gender: Male
Relation to Head: Head
Residence: Catskill, Greene, New York, USA
District: E.D. 3
Household number: 125
Line Number: 23
Household Members:
Name Age
Peter J Overbaugh 59
Girtrude D Overbaugh 57 [Wife, born circa 1798]

Peter’s date of birth, date and place of baptism, parents names, from US Dutch Reformed Church Records for Katskill Conewaga PA and Six Mile Run NJII, Book 19, for Catskill, New York, page 149 found in June 2019:
Name: Pieter Overbagh
Event Type: Baptism
Birth Date: 5 Sep 1795
Baptism Date: 4 Oct 1795
Baptism Place: Saugerties, Ulster, New York, USA
Father: Jacobus Overbagh
Mother: Christina Eman
Witness: Petrus Overbagh
Witness: Rendeltje Sammon