Name, approximate year of birth, country of birth, occupation, from USA 1905 Census for Catskill, Greene County, State of New York Census, found in June 2019:
Name: Benjamin W Overbaugh
Birth Year: abt 1850
Birth Place: United States
Age: 55
Gender: Male
Race: White
Residence Year: 1905
Residence: Catskill, Greene, New York, USA
Relationship to Head: Father
Election District: 04
Occupation: Day Labourer
Household Members:
Name Age
Roy E Overbaugh 26 [Son]
Martha T Overbaugh 23 [Daughter-in-law]
Benjamin W Overbaugh 55
Francis M Overbaugh 58 [Wife, born circa 1847]
Floyd A Overbaugh 26 [Son, born circa 1879]
Irma F Overbaugh 2 [Granddaughter, born circa 1903]

Result from USA 1875 New York State Census for Catskill, Greene County, found in June 2019:
Name: Benjamin Overbaugh
Age: 25
Gender: Male
Birth Year: abt 1850
Residence Date: 1 Jun 1875
Residence Place: Catskill, Greene, New York, USA
Election District: E.D. 04
Household number: 170
Relation to Head: Head
Spouse's name: Frances Overbaugh
Born: Greene
Line Number: 12
Sheet Number: 19
Occupation: Teamster (Drove a team of draft animals)
Household Members:
Name Age
Benjamin Overbaugh 25
Frances Overbaugh 26
Eugene Benit 73 [Father-in-law, born circa 1802]
Elizabeth Benit 63 [Mother-in-law, born circa 1812]

Entry of marriage record for son, Benjamin, from New York State Marriage Index for 1908-1923 for Greene, page 57, found in June 2019:
Name: Benjamin Overbaugh
Gender: Male
Spouse: Frances Bennett
Child: Floyd A Overbaugh

Name of parent’s and siblings, from USA 2nd July 1870 Federal Census for Catskill, Greene County, New York State, found in June 2019:
Name: Benjamin W Overbaugh
Age in 1870: 20
Birth Year: abt 1850
Birthplace: New York State
Dwelling Number: 529
Home in 1870: Catskill, Greene, New York
Race: White
Gender: Male
Occupation: Farm Laborer
Inferred Father: James P Overbaugh
Inferred Mother: Sally A Overbaugh
Household Members:
Name Age
James P Overbaugh 53 [Father, born circa 1817]
Sally A Overbaugh 53 [Mother, born circa 1817]
John Overbaugh 27 [Brother born circa 1843]
Benjamin W Overbaugh 20 [Brother, born circa 1850]
Ackman V G Overbaugh 16 [Brother, born circa 1854]
Sarah E Overbaugh 24 [Born circa 1843]
Minnie L Overbaugh 7/12 [7 months], Birth Month Oct [Therefore born October 1869]

Different initial for second name “D”, slightly different estimate of year of birth “1851”, from USA 1855 New York State Census for Town Catskill, Greene County, found in June 2019:
Benjamin D Overbaugh 4 [Son, born circa 1851]